If John McEnroe Had Been a Surgeon…


It has been just over 30 years since the famous John McEnroe tennis tirade enshrining the phrase “You cannot be serious!” took place.  The event was triggered by a service ace which was called out.  In general, it was a case of a specialist (the tennis player) unhappy with the performance of a utility figure (the judge).  How does this relate to medicine and surgery?

Surgeons sometimes have tantrums in the operating room.  This isn’t a surprise to anyone who has spent time in or around operating rooms, but it might be to a general reader.  The reasons for tantrums vary, as do their frequency.  A lot depends on the personality of the surgeon.  Some never have tantrums.  Others have them every day, sometimes every case.

There is a lot written these days about “disruptive physicians”, and this kind of behavior is probably improving.  What is clear is that under an employed model, surgeon tantrums will be less tolerated.   I speculate that two factors will be important in evaluating the response to a disruptive surgeon: 1) The surgeon’s financial contribution to the hospital, and 2) How rare is his specialty?  Low-volume surgeons in common fields should not try to imitate John McEnroe very often.

But why do surgeons have tantrums?  It is important to realize that the person with the most at stake during any operation is the patient.  Next in line is the surgeon.  If something goes wrong, it is the surgeon who faces the family, who manages the complication, who gets the malpractice suit, and who faces the medical board.  Sadly, not all surgeons are of high character, but most are.  And they take it personally when preventable problems threaten their patients.  There are plenty of things that take place in operating rooms that can frustrate surgeons; distracting staff shift changes, waits for equipment that should have been available, staff not familiar with certain equipment, and the list goes on.  I recently heard of a surgeon who was frustrated that the operating room did not have a specific item that had been requested over a week before in preparation for a certain case.  I can picture that scenario playing out as follows:

Surgeon:  “Okay we can open the [special item].”

Staff:  “We don’t have that at this facility.”

Surgeon:  “What do you mean you don’t have it?  You can’t be serious.  You CANNOT BE SERIOUS!  I specifically called for that over a week ago!  The patient is under anesthesia, we’re half way through this case and you’re calling around looking for what you should have had?”

Now, I don’t condone tantrums by surgeons or by anyone else for that matter.  They are not part of how rational adults should behave.  But I’m sure they occur in every sector of the economy from time to time.  And I understand why they sometimes happen in surgery.  Yes, the surgeon should have confirmed the item was there before beginning the case.  But for the surgeon to verify every conceivable detail prior to the case is not possible.  At some point the facility must be accountable.  One way to improve care is to realize that paying attention to what the surgeon requests is not about tolerating tantrums or coddling primadonnas; it’s about having good systems in place so there are no mistakes.  That is better for everyone, especially the patients.

And by the way, John McEnroe went on to win that 1981 Wimbledon match, tantrum and all.  He also won the tournament.

About these ads

Tags: , , ,

One response to “If John McEnroe Had Been a Surgeon…”

  1. Stephen McClure says :

    HealthStream recently launched E-learning courseware to help hospital staff learn to handle and defuse the negative effects of disruptive behavior.

    It can be found here:

    http://catalog.healthstream.com/Pages/Product.aspx?id=a14875c2-0ee7-4273-ad92-6b923533bbb4&ProductName=Disruptive Behaviors and Their Negative Impact on Patient Safety

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 190 other followers

%d bloggers like this: